Lay it Down College Football Bowl Games
This pains me to write this. Really. Painful -because I LOVE football. I used to say, if there is football on TV somewhere, I will probably watch it. I go into withdrawal right after the Pro Bowl. I pine throughout the summer waiting for September to usher in another football season. I dread the endless highlights of baseball on ESPN during the summer. How many different ways can I see a homerun, a diving catch, a 6-4-3 double-play. It gets old, real quick. Baseball doesn’t matter till September and October. Basketball ends in June. Then, nothing.
Summer is painful. The NFL Europe is defunct. We don’t get coverage of the CFL (Canadian Football League) –trust me, in the summer, I will watch it. Arena Football just does not cut it for me – although I do watch it out of desperation. I even watch replays of the previous season’s games on the NFL Network. Yea, it’s a sickness, I know.
I get a dose of what’s to come with the Combine and the Draft. Then more nothing. I wait.
I wait for irrelevant Pre-Season games. I wait for the contract holdouts. Then the final roster cuts. The call to enter the Fantasy Football Leagues. So I long for the return of Chris Berman and Tom Jackson calling the highlights on ESPN. I long for Hank Williams Jr. and the Monday Night Countdown. The double headers on Sunday. Sunday Night games, Thursday Night Games. And of course, College Football Saturdays.
What I love most about College Football – every week matters. Each season is fantastic. Last year no team finished undefeated – who gets to play in the National Championship Game? What a great season this was – who gets to represent the Big 12? The Big 12 – what drama, 5 team ranked in the top 15 at one point- Texas, Texas Tech, Oklahoma, Oklahoma State , Mizzou, - and you saw how that played out. Texas beat OU, Texas Tech beat Texas, but OU blewout Texas Tech, so who gets to play for the Big 12 Championship . . . . .
The SEC was packed. If you come out of the SEC unscathed, you’re pretty much playing for the national championship (#2 Florida v #1 Alabama). FANTASTIC! Oregon State upsets USC in the PAC-10. There were some many compelling stories and performances.
Then Bowl Season for the FBS Football Bowl Subdivision comes around and totally dilutes the importance of the regular season. Many people advocate having a playoff like in 1-AA (or the FCS -Football Championship Subdivision as it is now called). At least there is a goal, an endpoint in a playoff system. With the endless Bowl games, the only goal is to devalue the meaning of the regular season games.
There was a point when the bowl games that mattered were the Sugar, Fiesta, Orange, and Rose Bowl. You also had other major bowl games such as the Citrus and Cotton Bowls. Now, the list seems endless.
In the 1999-2000 season, there were 18 bowl games, with one game played before Christmas, two on Christmas Day, and then continuing till the 4th of January for the National Championship game.
the list: Sugar, Fiesta, Rose, Orange, Citrus, Cotton, Holiday, Motor City, Sun, Alamo, Peach, Liberty, Gator, Outback, Mobile, Insight.com, Oahu, and Aloha
For the current season, 2008-2009, that number has almost doubled with 35 bowls, with such notables as the Chick-fil-A Bowl, Papa Johns.com Bowl, Poinsettia Bowl, New Mexico Bowl, matter of fact here’s the complete list:
Eagle Bank Bowl, Chick-fil-A Bowl, Papa Johns.com Bowl, Poinsettia Bowl, New Mexico Bowl, magicJack St. Petersburg Bowl, Pioneer Las Vegas Bow, R + L Carriers’ New Orleans Bowl, San Diego County Credit Union Poinsettia Bowl, Sheraton Hawai’i Bowl, Motor City Bowl, Meineke Car Care Bowl, Champs Sports Bowl, Emerald Bowl, PetroSun Independence Bowl, Valero Alamo Bowl, Roady’s Humanitarian Bowl, Texas Bowl, Pacific Life Holiday Bowl, Bell Helicopter Armed Forces Bowl, Brut Sun Bowl, Gaylord Hotels Music City Bowl, Insight Bowl, Outback Bowl, Konica Minolta Gator Bowl, Capital One Bowl, Rose Bowl presented by Citi, Fed Ex Orange Bowl, AT&T Cotton Bowl, Autozone Liberty Bowl, AllState Sugar Bowl, International Bowl, Tostitos Fiesta Bowl, GMAC Bowl, and of course the BCS National Championship Game.
I got issues!! Ok . . . .
- I’m from Texas, but the Texas Bowl has to go. There’s already the Cotton Bowl.
- Aloha or Oahu Bowl- choose one. The games are in the same stadium, in a double header!
- What is so International about a game between Buffalo (8-5) and Connecticut (7-5) played in Toronto?
- Motor City Bowl? Give the money it takes to put this on as well as the naming rights money the Auto industry seeking a bailout.
- Meineke Car Care – seriously? They make enough money from changing oil and replacing brakes?
- How big are St. Petersburg, Shreveport, Birmingham, Boise, Fort Worth, El Paso
- Somebody is really going to El Paso? For real?
- At least Citi was able to say, Rose Bowl presented by Citi!
Here are some of the other names over the years that shouldn't have been Bowls either:
Insight.com, Micron PC, Humanitarian, Music City (99-00), Carquest, Copper, Independence, (95-96)
A look at the names of the Bowl Games tells who or what is to blame for this sacrilege. If you have enough money you can get the naming rights to a Bowl (of Stadium in any case – another issue for another day) or you can just CREATE a Bowl if you feel so inclined. Not that I’m a hard traditionalist, but enough already.
I’m going to make it simple :
- if you have lost 3 games or more, then you should not be in a bowl game.
- If you are 1 game over .500 – a 6-5 record, why are you even wasting everyone’s time. In 2001 Univ of North Texas went to the New Orleans Bowl game with a 5-6 record (albeit a Sun Belt Conference record of 5-1). They won their conference, but my question is: does every conference deserve to have a bowl game?
- If there is more than one game in the same stadium or city, then there is a problem:
- Aloha and Oahu Bowl: same stadium
- Florida Citrus Bowl : Capital One Bowl ,Champs Sports Bowl – same stadium
- Phoenix: Fiesta Bowl, Insight Bowl
- New Orleans: New Orleans Bowl, Sugar Bowl
- Dallas: Fort Worth might as well be Dallas - Yes to an Armed Forces Bowl, just not in Fort Worth, Cotton bowl
In 2000, there were 13 teams with 5 or more losses, 6 of them lost 6 games..
So I humbly beg you, College Football Powers That Be, please Lay It Down to some of these extraneous Bowl games.





